Banned for Life from the Miami-Dade Metrorail

Be sure to read about the eventual resolution of this debacle here.

Wow. What a day. I’m 47 years old and got my first camera, a Canon AT-1, when I was 15 of so. In the intervening 32 years, I’ve made photographs both professionally and for my own personal enjoyment in 50 countries and in most of these beautiful United States of America. Photography has allowed me to see and experienced a lot of things, and yesterday I had an experience that I won’t forget for a long time. I’ll bet that some of the other folks involved – including but not limited to my friend Carlos Miller, various employees of a Miami company called “50 State Security,” three officers from the Miami Police Department, two officers from the Miami-Dade Police Department, and a gentleman who identified himself as an agent of the federal Department of Homeland Security – won’t forget it for a while either.

Where to begin? Those of you who are professional photographers can doubtless recount stories of this person or that person attempting to stop you from making photographs. It’s a common problem, and one that’s been around probably since Matthew Brady’s day. In some cases, these individuals have been well within their rights to stop us from photographing. Just off the top of my head I recall when:

  • The police in Cotonou, Benin, a small country in West Africa, told me to stop photographing on a city street back in the mid-1990’s and I had to comply.
  • A soldier armed with an AK-47 near Kikwit, Zaire (now the Democratic Republic of the Congo), stopped me from making photographs of a lightning storm from a bridge in 1993 and I did as I was told.
  • People in authority or who claimed to be in authority have asked or told me to stop photographing in Outer Mongolia, Bangladesh, Mozambique, India, Sri Lanka, Brazil, and probably in other countries. I forget.
  • As recently as March of this year, while I was on assignment in Lagos, Nigeria, police officers detained me after they saw me making photographs of the city skyline from a public roadway. Though I stopped making pictures, I refused to get into their police vehicle and go to the station. We ended up in a bit of a stalemate for an hour or so, until they said I was free to go. (This is a story that ends very humorously and I will blog about it at another time. The police officers and I ended up being quite good friends!)

I generally stop making photographs, at least for a while, when I’m told to do so during a visit to a foreign country. Why? Well, because the rights of individuals in the countries I named above, and indeed in every country in the wide world except here in the US of A, aren’t protected by something called the First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States of America. That’s the little clause that here in America the Beautiful famously establishes individuals’ rights to freely assemble, to speak freely, to express themselves freely in manners other than speech, and to exercise freedom of the press.

Which brings us back to yesterday’s excellent adventure.

As a graduate student in the multimedia journalism program at the University of Miami’s School of Communication, I was assigned a project as part of Professor Sam Terilli’s 2010 Media Law and Ethics Seminar (CNJ 614) that called upon me to create a report concerning one of the class topics – the “legal and ethical issues concerning First Amendment theories and practices regarding defamation, privacy, freedom of information, free press vs. fair trial, reporter privilege, access to media, intellectual property, obscenity, broadcasting, and new media.”

Back in October or so, 2009, I had been harassed by a security guard because I brought a camera into Miami’s Overtown Metrorail station. At the time this seemed to be really unfair, unkind, and, most of all, quite unconstitutional, so for the media law assignment I decided to explore the rights that a person has, or does not have, to make photographs on, in, and around Miami-Dade Transit’s (MDT’s) Metrorail system.

Though I already felt that I had a pretty good layman’s understanding of the relevant laws, and I was certain that Professor Terilli had taught me well in CNJ 614, I wanted to double and triple check my facts. After a little work on Monday, June 28, I found that, as Victor Perlman, general counsel for the American Society of Media Photographers, was quoted saying in this NPR story, “If [someone is] photographing something that is visible from a public space while on a public space, there are virtually no laws that really prohibit that.” I know that Mr. Perlman is very good at what he does, and his statement confirmed my layman’s understanding of the law.

With this in mind, I began to exchange e-mails and phone calls with Eric Muntan, MDT’s Chief of Safety and Security and one of the nicest and most helpful public servants I’ve ever encountered. Mr. Muntan not only responded to my e-mails quickly, he sent me a copy of section 30b-5(2) of the Miami-Dade County Code, which regulates commercial activities on or around MDT property. Mr. Muntan also rearranged his schedule on Tuesday, June 29, in order for me to conduct a telephone interview with him at 7:00 am. As we began the interview, he graciously consented for me to make an audio recording of the conversation to ensure the accuracy of my contemporaneous notes. Would that all public officials were so willing to assist their constituents.

During our discussion, Mr. Muntan shared with me that his first concern is for the safety and security of Metrorail’s passengers, but he also expressed a sincere appreciation for the fact that some people, for one reason or another, will want to make photographs of the metro trains and facilities and that MDT needs to accommodate these folks. To this end, Mr. Muntan said, “We bend over backward to accommodate any type of media request that we can. Heck, we’ve shut down the system for Burn Notice and we did Bad Boyz II down here.” He explained that while commercial photography on Metrorail property is prohibited without a permit, there is no such prohibition against photography that is personal, journalistic, or, in his words, “Johnny Tourist” photography. When I asked him how his officers distinguish between commercial photography and personal photography, he said, “If you tell us that you’re not using the pictures for commercial work and they’re (for) personal use, at that point in time the security officers, and/or the MDT representative should feel that his question is answered and at that point you’re free to take pictures until the next train comes or whatever.” (The irony of this statement will hit you as you continue to read…)

Here is the recording of our conversation, edited for brevity and clarity:

Telephone Interview with Miami-Dade Transit Chief of Security Eric Muntan

WOW! It all seemed so simple! The only detail that I felt I didn’t clearly understand was something Mr. Muntan called MDT’s “post orders,” which he said set forth the “standard operating procedure” for guards on MDT property, including procedures for enforcing county code section 30b. I asked for a copy of these post orders, even a copy redacted for security purposes, and Mr. Muntan promised to have ask his staff mail it to me. Unfortunately, I never received the document, despite having followed up with Mr. Muntan about it via e-mail.

In any event, because I had read about the county’s well documented problems with the Wackenhut guards who provided security for the MDT stations up until November 3, 2009, I thought it would be judicious of me to chat with a representative of the current company that the county contracts to do the work, “50 State Security,” and get his take on things.

After several phone calls that were never returned, yesterday morning at about 11:30 I finally made contact with the company’s president, John Williams. His interpretation of “30b” and his willingness to trust MDT passengers when they tell his security guards why they’re making pictures was as different from Mr. Muntan’s as day is from night… as fire is from ice… as love is from hate… as steak is from eggs… um, well, you get the picture.

Mr. Williams stated, “All we would know is what you tell us and we would not stand by that. We would ask you to identify yourself and if you didn’t have a permit we would ask you to leave. In fact… you would have to leave or we would notify law enforcement of the situation. We would need approval from the county, a form that the county provides us.” He went on to say that anyone who does not have that form would be prevented from making photographs on MDT property.

Hmmm… a conundrum…

After speaking with Mr. Williams, it seemed to me that the only way to get to the bottom of the situation and to really understand what rights a MDT passenger has or does not have with regard to photography was to head to a nearby metro station, make some photos, and see what would happen.

Though I hoped to make photographs in and around the Douglas Road metro stop to send to my lovely wife in Richmond and to use in my report, and to then be on my merry way, I prepared for the worst. If Mr. Williams’ people were trained as he said they were, rather than as Mr. Muntan said they should be, then there was a decent chance that I would be arrested while making my pictures and go to jail. So I took a few precautions:

  • I sent an e-mail to my local attorney, Sam Terilli (yep, the same man who taught my media law class), letting him know where I was going and what I was hoping to do there.
  • I wrote Sam’s cell number in permanent ink on several public and not so public places on my body.
  • I printed a copy of the e-mail Mr. Muntan sent me that included the text of the “30b” statute and stuck it in my pocket.

Finally, I called my friend Carlos Miller, whose blog, “Photography Is Not a Crime,” may be the most comprehensive database anywhere of incidents of police harassment of photographers. (Carlos says he has chronicled more than 800 such incidents since April, 2007.) I wanted someone to be at the metro stop with me to document anything that was going to happen, and Carlos agreed to meet me at the station with his video camera.

Carlos and I arrived at the station about 2:30pm. I proceeded to make some photos and videos with my Canon 5d Mark II, and Carlos proceed to make videos of me making videos. I can only describe the events that followed as absolutely astounding.

Not astounding because a person in a uniform tried to prevent me from making photographs; astounding because it all took place in the United States of America. We weren’t in Benin, or Zaire, or Brazil, or Outer Mongolia or any of the countries I mentioned at the beginning of this little novella. We were in the United States, once known as the Home of the Free, standing on public property, property that my tax dollars helped to purchase, being denied constitutional rights that my uncle Charles Constance, Jr., in the Battle of the Bulge, my father Charles Edward Ledford in Korea, and my brother Lt. Col. Edward Curtis Ledford who by the time he returns home in March will have spent more than three years in Afghanistan and ten months in Iraq, each selflessly defended.

Carlos and I had not even left the parking lot when a “50 State Security” guard approached me and said that due to “terrorism” it was “against the law” for me to make photographs at the station. From there, things went steadily downhill.

I purchased a ticket so I could ride the metro down to the University of Miami station and back, about a two-dollar investment, but I was physically prevented from entering the turnstile by a “50 State Security” guard. The guards called the Miami Police and three officers eventually arrived. Although I tried to show the officers the e-mail from Mr. Muntan, the chief of security for MDT, the officers either wouldn’t read the e-mail or told me that it was irrelevant and that the private security guards were within their rights to bar me from the station.

Unbelievably, I was told by one of the police officers that if I was to walk through the turnstile and the security guard was to physically detain me, that I would be arrested for assault. Though I kept hoping that cooler heads would prevail, it seemed that the more police officers and security personnel that arrived at the scene, the more adamant and single-minded they became about preventing me from entering the station, with or without a camera. (This in spite of the fact that at least one person with a camera entered the station and another exited the station during the three-plus hours that I spent trying to get in.)

None of the ten or so police officers and security guards that eventually showed up for this little feté – including one individual who claimed to be with Homeland Security – would break rank. The Thin Blue Line was drawn taught, and it was not going to be broken by means of reason, nor facts, nor even a printed copy of the county statute this fraternity was so determined to enforce. Of this they were certain.

They took down both my and Carlos’ identification information, several times actually. A City of Miami cop called me a liar to my face. A Miami-Dade County officer who would only give his name as “S. Ruesga” told me with a straight face that I clearly was making photos for commercial gain because I would gain a “grade” from my professor for this project. He didn’t see the illogic of his statement even when I informed him of he fact that I’m paying the University of Miami about $75,000 to attend graduate school, though I think he appreciated the fact that our conversation had begun to deteriorate into something akin to the “battle of wits” between Vizzini and Westley in “The Princess Bride”:

Here is an audio clip of the similar conversation in which Mr. Ruesga and I found ourselves:

“But I Would Know That You Would Know That I Know… and…”

And here’s a clip of the longer conversation. At the end, Mr. Ruesga confesses that he isn’t really clear about the law that he was trying to enforce:

Semi-fascinating Exchange Between Miami-Dade Police Officer Ruesga and Me

The “homeland security” guy stated more than once that I had actually said that I was making photographs for commercial purposes. Of course because this will probably be his defense in any future legal action that may grow out of this incident, he would not allow me to correct him even though I tried several times.

So eventually, Carlos and I left, but not before getting as many of the officers’ names and badge numbers as possible, and, best of all, not before allowing Sam Terilli to listen over my phone as the “homeland security” guy dared Sam to issue him a subpoena.

Oh… and not before we were informed by several of the brethren that both Carlos and I were now banned for life from riding the Miami-Dade metro. I leave it up to Sam and the courts to ensure that by the middle of August I actually am allowed to ride the metro. I’m planning to ride the trains as I commute to the university for the fall semester, when I start teaching basic photojournalism to malleable young minds that need to understand that the rights they take for granted every day can only be guaranteed if someone is willing to fight back when those rights are threatened.

“You have the right to free speech. As long as you’re not dumb enough to actually try it.”
-Joe Strummer of The Clash
(1952 – 2002)

Be sure to read about the eventual resolution of this debacle here.

130 Responses to “Banned for Life from the Miami-Dade Metrorail”

  1. May 12, 2016 at 9:03 pm #

    Caro MillorConcordo com sua posição. Vou dar uma dica: depois que a missão e visão estiverem claramente definidas, deve-se buscar duas ou tres palavras fortes para resumir as duas declaracões. Eu chamo essas palavras de mantras corporativos.Veja p.e. o mantra da Natura: “Bem Estar Bem” ou da Disney: “Alegrar as pessoas”. Obrigado e um forte abraço!

  2. Common Skin Disease May 14, 2016 at 2:33 pm #

    Please do not assume that a person with acne is “dirty”. Your
    face is the first thing someone is presented with
    upon meeting you, so your outward appearance
    and skin condition is undoubtedly and inevitably noticed.
    If you would like to remove them naturally,
    it is important for you to check this article out that gives better information on how to solve the problems of acne scars naturally.

  3. jacks blowjob lessons pdf May 21, 2016 at 1:49 pm #

    Swee blog! I found it while searching on Yahoo News.

    Do you have any suggestions on how to get listed in Yahoo News?
    I’ve been tryig for a while but I never seem to get there!

  4. Jacks Blow job lessons May 24, 2016 at 2:26 pm #

    Please do not assume that a person with acne is “dirty”. More importantly, you
    will learn the best ways to counter each of these contributing factors of acne.

    Anti-oxidant chemicals are valued for their wide healing actions.

  5. bronchitis cough and eczema June 13, 2016 at 7:15 am #

    There are definitely a variety of particulars like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I provide the ideas above as basic inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where an important factor might be working in honest good faith. I don?t know if greatest practices have emerged around things like that, however I’m sure that your job is clearly recognized as a good game. Both boys and girls really feel the impression of just a moment’s pleasure, for the remainder of their lives.

  6. June 27, 2016 at 11:15 am #

    This is really interesting, You are a very skilled blogger. I’ve joined your rss feed and look forward to more of your wonderful post. Also, I have shared your site in my social networks!

  7. http://www./ July 21, 2016 at 2:45 am #

    Pathetic how the media continually parrots the ECUSA’s version that the split is completely due to gay ordination/marriage and has nothing to do with the [ultimately] more important doctrinal failings of Schori and other senior leadership. When the senior denominational leadership starts denying the divinity of Christ and expects to be taken seriously, there are some major issues at stake.

  8. prednisone August 10, 2016 at 1:50 pm #

    Yup, that’ll do it. You have my appreciation.

  9. Carl September 13, 2016 at 12:16 am #

    If you are interested in topic: earn money online lahore – you should read about Bucksflooder first

  10. October 19, 2016 at 11:38 am #

    so if you get CBS to fire this guy, you are on par with Jackson & Sharpton. Ain’t that grand.stop with your whining. Let it go- if you react as stupid as some other guy, it still means you are stupid


  1. Photographers Banned for Life from Metro for Taking Pictures - July 1, 2010

    […] Ledford’s account of what happened, and here’s […]

  2. Photojournalists "banned for life" from Miami-Dade Metrorail - July 2, 2010

    […] "banned for life" from Miami-Dade Metrorail Banned for Life from the Miami-Dade Metrorail | Very Stretchy Indeed Photography has allowed me to see and experienced a lot of things, and yesterday I had an […]

  3. Video: Fotografer bannlysta på livstid från tunnelbana i USA | Carlbom Foto - July 2, 2010

    […] ni veta mer om omständigheterna kring filmen ovan så är blogginläggen hos Stretch Ledford och Carlos Miller mycket läsvärda, då man där får höra deras […]

  4. Media Law 2.0 » Photojournalism students banned from MetroRail - July 2, 2010

    […] read the full account of the incident here and […]

  5. DONTBESQUARE JAMZ! » Photographer Banned For Life For Shooting Photos At The Miami-Dade Metrorail - July 2, 2010

    […] Ledford’s account of what happened, and here’s Miller’s. (No Ratings Yet)  Loading […]

  6. Ignorance of the Law Is No Excuse. Unless You're in Law Enforcement. - Hit & Run : Reason Magazine - July 2, 2010

    […] Miller's account here. Ledman's is here. […]

  7. Ignorance of the Law Is No Excuse. Unless You Work in Law Enforcement. | The Agitator - July 2, 2010

    […] Miller’s account here. Ledman’s is here. […]

  8. How Stupid Can Cops Be? - July 2, 2010

    […] More here. […]

  9. Banned for life - US Message Board - Political Discussion Forum - July 2, 2010

    […] Banned for Life from the Miami-Dade Metrorail | Very Stretchy Indeed Photography Is Not A Crime __________________ A human being should be able to change a diaper, plan an invasion, butcher a hog, conn a ship, design a building, write a sonnet, balance accounts, build a wall, set a bone, comfort the dying, take orders, give orders, cooperate, act alone, solve equations, analyze a new problem, pitch manure, program a computer, cook a tasty meal, fight efficiently, die gallantly. Specialization is for insects. Be extremely subtle, even to the point of formlessness. Be extremely mysterious, even to the point of soundlessness. Thereby you can be the director of the opponent's fate. […]

  10. We were permanently banned from the Miami-Dade Metrorail for taking photos | Photography is Not a Crime - July 3, 2010

    […] Check out his version of the story here. […]

  11. We were permanently banned from the Miami-Dade Metrorail for taking photos : Federal Jack - July 4, 2010

    […] Check out his version of the story here. […]

  12. The Progressive Mind » We were permanently banned from the Miami-Dade Metrorail for taking photos | Photography is Not a Crime - July 5, 2010

    […] out his version of the story here. […]

  13. Today Is July 5, Not July 4. In Fact, EVERY Day Is July 5. | Popehat - July 5, 2010

    […] 2.  “How could I go to school after that and pledge allegiance and sit through good government bullshit?” […]

  14. Police Stop Journalists From Photographing Metrorail System | JetLib News - July 5, 2010

    […] stopped the pair first. They then called in local police. The private firm and the police then threatened the two with arrest, demanded their identification (to check them against a terrorist watch list), demanded multiple […]

  15. 2 periodistas "baneados" de por vida del metro de Miami por intentar tomar fotos [Eng] - July 5, 2010

    […] 2 periodistas "baneados" de por vida del metro de Miami por intentar tomar fotos [Eng]  por querizas hace 3 segundos […]

  16. Militant Libertarian » Just Making It Up As They Go Along - July 7, 2010

    […] Balko, Carlos Miller from Photography Is Not A Crime, and Stretch Ledford, a veteran photojournalist currently pursuing a Masters degree in Multimedia Journalism at the […]

  17. Expulsados de por vida por realizar fotos en un aparcamiento público - Backfocus - July 9, 2010

    […] | Photography Is Not A Crime y Stretch Photography derechos Puedes seguir la actividad de este artículo mediante su feed RSS 2.0. También puedes […]

  18. » Blog Archive » Just Making It Up As They Go Along - July 9, 2010

    […] Radley Balko, Carlos Miller from Photography Is Not A Crime, and Stretch Ledford, a veteran photojournalist currently pursuing a Masters degree in Multimedia Journalism at the […]

  19. Non-Security and Civil Liberties | Security Generation - July 14, 2010

    […] Miami photojournalists, Carlos Miller and Charles Ledford, attempted to enter the Metrorail system to take pictures of stations and trains, but were instead […]

  20. Photo protest against Miami-Dade Metrorail is on - August 8, 2010

    […] people in charge, but the point of this protest is to show them that this is not just about me or Stretch Ledford, who along with me was “banned for life” from the Metrorail for taking photos, but […]

Leave a Reply: